Are You Middle Class?
by Juno MonetaJune 9th, 2008, 9:20 pm
When you listen to Senator McCain and Senator Obama talking about what they want to do for the middle class, it sounds pretty good. Senator McCain wants to repeal the Alternative Minimum Tax for middle class families. Senator Obama wants to simplify tax filings for middle class Americans and offer more tax breaks. Wow, so whichever one wins the presidency, I can rest assured that he is looking out for me! Or not. Am I middle class? Are you? What does middle class mean?
Unfortunately, there is no definite answer to this question. While economists have some consensus that middle class American families are those that earn between $30,000 and $100,000 per year (that’s per household, not per person), politicians are slippery about owning up to who they are referring to when they talk about the generous gifts they plan to heap on this vague “middle class.”
Senator Obama recently hinted that households making $97,500 are not part of the middle class because only 6% of Americans make that amount or higher. Does that mean that a New York couple, in which both parties make $50,000, are “rich” and therefore deserving of punitive tax hikes due to their evil richness? (By the way, Americans earning more than $85,000 already pay about 80% of all U.S. taxes.)
To be fair, Senator McCain is trickier to pin down on this issue of exactly what group of people would benefit from his middle class policy proposals.
Then there’s the interesting American phenomenon where most people, no matter what their incomes, define themselves as middle class. They could be making $20K or $200K, but they think of themselves as middle class anyway.
Maybe this happens because to most of us, the term “middle class” conjures up a lifestyle and not a dollar amount. It’s that American dream lifestyle that includes home ownership in a good school district, two cars, one vacation per year, a little savings, and a college education for little Suzie and Billy so that they too can become middle class. “The company” takes care of the retirement savings and most healthcare costs, so mom and dad can rest easy. Swell.
There are some places in the country where that lifestyle can still be had for $50,000. There are other places like New York City and Washington, D.C. where that lifestyle is hard to come by, even for couples in which both parties make six figure salaries. Overinflated home prices certainly contribute to the elusiveness of the middle class scenario. But there’s also the fact that we have to pay for a lot of expensive stuff that previous generations didn’t have to worry about-such as high health care costs, crippling student loans, and retirement savings.
Clearly everyone wants to be part of the middle class-that’s why we all say we ARE middle class. Lower-income folks want to feel that their hard work has paid off, while wealthier people want to feel likeable, down to earth, and all that. Plus, almost everyone feels pinched or like they have to make compromises, no matter where they sit on the economic ladder. Plus, none of us want to be cut out of those great perks promised by political candidates to only the “middle class.” But perhaps this is a bad thing. Perhaps it’s okay to NOT be middle class, as we currently think of it. Perhaps wanting to be middle class and live that dream is what got us into this sub-prime loan mortgage crisis. Maybe that’s what gets so many people our age into credit card debt. Maybe that’s why so many people haven’t saved or invested enough for retirement, because they’re too busy trying to have that “American dream” lifestyle.
Maybe it’s time for a new American dream - one that fits in with today’s realities. Maybe it’s time to redefine the middle class and make it a new target to strive for-a lifestyle that focuses on financial security and smart decision making rather than one that depends on material possessions like houses and cars. How about this definition: debt-free, maxes out retirement contributions, fully insured (health, life, disability, auto, etc.), and has a little extra left over at the end of the month for a pleasure purchase of choice-shoes, a nice evening out, a gift to charity, or whatever you can afford that makes you happy.
Posted in Philosophy | No Comments »














